‘There’s no way they would ever know the difference’: Woman admits to swapping places with her twin sister after car and buggy crash that killed 2 Amish children

Left to right: Sarah Petersen, Samantha Petersen (Olmsted County Sheriff’s Office). A…

‘Yet another lie’: Mom of 3 missing boys says their jailed father lied to police, claiming kids were with Amish reality TV star and mystery writer after watching show in prison

Left top: Photos of brothers Alexander Skelton, Tanner Skelton, Andrew Skelton, who…

Unexpected Rules Amish Women Have To Follow

In general, modesty rules dictate many clothing choices made by an Amish…

Pregnant Amish Woman Found Dead Inside Her Home With 'Scalping' Wound

A Pennsylvania man was arrested on Saturday on suspicion of killing a…

‘The outside world doesn’t get in’: Slaying of pregnant Amish woman may have been a case of mistaken identity, suspect’s foster daughter says

Shawn Cranston appears in a booking photo from February 2024 (Crawford County…

Identical twins accused of swapping places charged with killing 2 Amish children after car rear-ends carriage

Identical twins from Minnesota are accused of swapping places after one of them, allegedly…

Daughter of Man Accused of Killing Pregnant Amish Woman Speaks Out: ‘I could never picture my dad being that cold-hearted monster’

The daughter of the man accused of murdering a pregnant Pennsylvania woman…

Suspect arrested in mysterious murder of pregnant Amish mom in remote Pa. farmhouse while 2 young kids were home

A 52-year-old Pennsylvania man has been arrested in connection with the grisly…

Arrest Made in Killing of Pregnant Pennsylvania Amish Woman, Rebekah Byler

Pennsylvania authorities have arrested a man in connection with the killing of…

Crime Stories with Nancy Grace: NO SUSPECT in Murder of Pregnant Amish Woman, 23

It’s just afternoon when Andy Byler and a friend arrive at the…