It seems like everyone who was even on one episode of Gilmore Girls has a story. Alan Blumenfeld was in four episodes as Rabbi David Barans, friend of Reverend Skinner (Jim Jansen). In his first appearance in season 3 of Gilmore Girls, Rabbi Barans’ left arm is in a cast, due to a real life injury Blumenfeld incurred. If you ever wondered why, Blumenfeld is still telling the story.

Blumenfeld was a guest on Scott Patterson’s I Am All In podcast on Jan. 11 to discuss his role on Gilmore Girls. Blumenfeld explained his cast and how nobody from the casting directors to the costume department noticed his arm was in a cast.