How Heather Gay got her black eye remains a mystery to fans of The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City. With only one episode left in season 3 of the Bravo series, many don’t think they’ll get answers about the black eye. So, fans have taken matters into their own hands and started coming up with theories about how the injury happened. Here are a few hilarious fan theories about Heather’s black eye, plus why some fans are annoyed with the RHOSLC Season 3 plot line.

How did Heather get a black eye? We might not know until ‘Ultimate Girls Trip’
After finding out Whitney Rose put her on a “friendship break,” Heather turned up in San Diego. The night ended with her and Jen Shah going topless poolside and, ultimately, Heather gaining a black eye. How she got that black eye is unclear, but one thing is for sure — Heather “doesn’t want to talk about it.”