After stepping into Katy Perry’s role for American Idol season 23, Carrie Underwood—season 4 winner and global music icon—has sparked conversations about her future with the series. Despite her success as a first-time judge alongside Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan, her hesitant comments after the finale hinted that she might not be returning for season 24.
Now, Life & Style has reported that Carrie is interested in continuing her judging role, but balancing it with her personal life remains a challenge. With a busy touring schedule, the country star struggles being away from her husband, Mike Fisher, and their sons, Isaiah (10) and Jacob (6). An insider revealed, “She’s constantly traveling. She misses Mike and the kids so much. They FaceTime all the time, and she uses every free moment to fly back home—but nothing replaces physically being with them.”
Still, according to the source, Carrie isn’t ready to walk away from American Idol just yet. “She genuinely loves doing the show,” the insider explained. “It’s a major opportunity and pays very well, but more than that, it’s something she truly enjoys. She loves the dynamic with Luke and Lionel, and the production team has made her feel incredibly welcome. What means the most to her is helping contestants navigate such a life-changing journey.”
The insider added that judging American Idol is deeply emotional for Carrie because she can relate to the contestants on a personal level. “She’s walked in their shoes. She knows exactly what it feels like to be under that spotlight,” they said.
However, the toll it takes is undeniable. “By the end of a filming day, she’s emotionally drained. Instead of relaxing at home with Mike or reading bedtime stories to her boys, she’s alone in a hotel room, staring at them on a screen. It’s incredibly tough.”
What Carrie Underwood’s Family Struggles Could Mean For Her American Idol Return
Carrie Might Be Considering Stepping Away
While Carrie’s experience as a season 23 judge seems to have been positive overall, her emotional struggle being separated from her family may lead to a difficult decision. Given how important her role as a mother and wife is to her, she may ultimately choose not to return if it means continuing long stretches away from her loved ones.
Why Carrie Underwood Should Return For American Idol Season 24
There’s More Potential To Unlock
Carrie’s time on American Idol showcased her passion and empathy, and fans appreciated her chemistry with the other judges. However, being “America’s Sweetheart” since her season 4 victory, Carrie isn’t used to public criticism—and she encountered some.
Early in the audition rounds, Carrie admitted she feared being perceived as too harsh if she critiqued contestants negatively. As a result, some viewers found her feedback too mild and even labeled her as overly supportive rather than constructively critical. When she finally gave direct advice during the Top 5 episode—particularly to winner Jamal Roberts—some fans accused her of favoring specific contestants, like runner-up John Foster. It seemed that no matter what she said, backlash followed, which may have affected her confidence.
Despite this, Carrie’s judging style has real promise. Watching her develop into a more balanced and confident mentor would be exciting. I genuinely hope she returns for season 24. But if the pull of family is stronger, and she decides to step back, I completely respect that. Whatever she chooses, I’ll continue to support her, just as I have since her unforgettable season 4 audition.
