Andrew Conley Murder

The Andrew Conley murder case is a tragic and disturbing example of the lengths some people will go to fulfill their twisted desires.

The Andrew Conley murder case shocked the nation when it came to light in 2009. 

Andrew Conley, a teenager from Indiana, was convicted of killing his ten-year-old brother and sentenced to life without parole. However, he is now seeking a new sentence, claiming that his original sentence was too harsh. 

The Andrew Conley murder case is a tragic and disturbing example of the lengths some people will go to fulfill their twisted desires. 

While Andrew Conley was the one who physically carried out the murder, Jake Brunette was equally guilty of his role in the planning and execution of the crime.

Andrew Conley Murder Case: What Happened?

On November 28, 2009, the Police were called to the Conley residence in Indiana after Andrew Conley’s Father discovered his ten-year-old son, Conner, dead in his bed.

At first, it was believed that Conner had died in his sleep, but upon closer inspection, it was discovered that he had been strangled. Andrew Conley was the prime suspect from the beginning, as he had confessed to the murder to his Father.

Conley
Andrew Conley (left) is appealing a life in prison sentence for the 2009 murder. (Source: eaglecountryonline.com)

During the investigation, Conley revealed that he had been planning the murder for several weeks and had strangled his brother with his bare hands. Conley also stated that he had been inspired by the television show “Dexter,” a show about a serial killer who only kills other killers.

You May Also Like: Deshawn Thomas Shot St Louis Homeless Man: 23-Year-Old Man Arrested And Charged With Murder

The trial of Andrew Conley took place in 2010 when he was found guilty of murder and was sentenced in prison without the possibility of parole. The judge cited the crime’s premeditated and particularly heinous nature as the reason for the harsh sentence.

Jake Brunette Arrested: Sentenced To 65 Years In Prison

Jake Brunette was arrested in December 2009 and was charged with conspiracy to commit murder. He pleaded guilty to the charge in 2010 and was sentenced to 65 years. 

Brunette
Jake Brunette mugshot picture. (Source: madisonin.mugshots)

While Andrew Conley was the one who committed the murder, he was not acting alone. He had an accomplice, Jake Brunette, who helped him plan and carry out the murder. Brunette was also Conley’s boyfriend at the time.

You May Also Like: John Brogan Murder Case: Kevin McHale Arrested and Charged After 83-Year-Old Man Found With Gunshot

The judge cited Brunette’s willingness to participate in the murder and his lack of remorse for the harsh sentence. Today, Brunette is serving his sentence in prison while Conley continues to fight for a new sentence. 

Where Is Jake Brunette Now?

Since his sentencing, Jake Brunette has been serving his time in prison. He is incarcerated at the Wabash Valley Correctional Facility in Indiana.

Despite being in prison, Brunette has made headlines recently after he sent a letter to Andrew Conley in which he apologized for his role in the murder.

In the letter, Brunette wrote, “I’m sorry for the pain I’ve caused you and your family. I’m sorry for being part of that night.”

You May Also Like: Nicole Bullock Age: How Old Was Durham Woman? Rodney Crawford Arrested For Murder At Motel

Conley has since publicly forgiven Brunette, stating that he believes his former boyfriend is genuinely remorseful for his actions. However, it remains to be seen if Brunette’s apology will affect Conley’s quest for a new sentence.