A decorated Royal Navy sailor killed himself after losing his ‘dream home’ when he complained about a low fence and the developer then refused to sell it to him, an inquest has heard.
Petty Officer Rob Minshull was furious after a £375,000 property in Cornwall was taken off the market when he questioned its 4ft fence, which was 2ft smaller than other homes on the development.
Mr Minshull, an Afghan war hero, and his wife Kerry complained after they were concerned it would allow people at a nearby Tesco store in Helston to see their two young daughters playing in the paddling pool in the garden.
Within days the developer had refused to sell them the property, withdrawing it from the market only to put back on for £75,000 more shortly afterwards. David Martin, of Graceloft Ltd, told his local paper at the time: ‘I increased the price to sell it again, but that’s only business. I don’t feel I’ve done anything wrong.’
Mrs Minshull told her husband’s inquest in Truro, Cornwall, this week that he ‘could not get past our losing the house’ in 2021. It sent him down a depression spiral, later worsened by fears about rising mortgage rates and the cost of living crisis.
Mrs Minshull told the coroner Emma Hillson: ‘This had a huge effect on Rob. He started drinking more and he could not get past the way we lost the house.’ The couple had spent £10,000 on fees, legal costs and even furniture when the sale collapsed.
Rob and Kerry Minshull lost their dream home over a fence and the veteran sailor never recovered from the stress, an inquest heard
A developer refused to sell Rob and Kerry Minshull their ‘for ever home’ in Helston, Cornwall, when they complained the 4ft fence was 2ft too low. He would later take his own life
The couple were concerned that the lower fence at the four-bed new build would allow people from a nearby Tesco to see their two young daughters playing in the paddling pool in the garden. The developer took it off the market for £375,000 and returned it to the market for £75,000. He said at the time it was ‘only business’
In December 2021 the 42-year-old, his wife and two daughters later moved to another property in Helston, Cornwall, but he considered it to be ‘second best’.
Mrs Minshull told the coroner: ‘Rob was the life and soul, everyone loved him. He was a brilliant husband and father and would do anything for anyone.’
She had earlier said the family had spent thousands of pounds on fees and goods for the four-bedroom new home. They had also paid for custom wardrobes and blinds.
She said in 2021: ‘It’s just broken my family completely. I’d never wish this to happen to anybody.’
Mr Minshull lost sleep and his appetite and was drinking more alcohol as a result of not buying the house. In October last year his wife found him hanged in the garage of that house early one morning.
The inquest heard Mr Minshull was also suffering with other stresses.
The aircraft engineer, who had joined the Royal Navy aged 17 and had served for 25 years on ships including HMS Illustrious and served in Afghanistan in 2009-10, was offered a promotion to Chief Petty Officer which he did not want.
He was concerned about his children and the rising cost of living and mortgage rates and he told his teaching assistant wife about recent suicide attempts.
He had been prescribed anti-depressants by Navy doctors but he feared, wrongly, that he would be medically discharged out of the senior service – and so he stopped taking them and was allowed back to his responsible job on aircraft engineering.
On the night he killed himself, he had told Mrs Minshull that he loved her, which she reciprocated, and he went back to bed. But at 4am she woke up and he was not in bed – and she found him in the garage.
Read Related Also: Kanye West Under Investigation for Battery After Throwing Woman’s Phone Away
After losing the house, Mr Minshull also become increasingly worried about rising interest rates and the cost of living crisis
Mr Minshull, pictured with his wife and children, had been prescribed anti-depressants by Navy doctors but he feared, wrongly, that he would be medically discharged out of the senior service – and so he stopped taking them
Captain Stuart Irwin, Commanding Officer of the Royal Naval Air Station at Culdrose, Cornwall, where Mr Minshull was based for most of his career, told the inquest an investigation was held.
He said most people who are referred to the service’s medical board are not discharged from the Navy – but their perception of that may be different.
He said close friends and colleagues in Mr Minshull’s small unit did not see any change in his behaviour and were shocked by his death.
He said he had spoken about the failed house purchase and rising living costs but said of his comrades ‘none of them saw it coming’.
The assistant coroner Ms Hillson recorded a suicide conclusion.
The family spoke to the Press at the time the house sale collapsed.
Mrs Minshull said she had sent a polite email to the builder saying: ‘I’m sorry to trouble you we’ve been to look at the property were really not happy about the fence.’
In an email thread between Mr and Mrs Minshull and the site manager, the couple have claimed that they were told not to worry.
But within days the estate agency handling the exchange is said to have contacted them to say David Martin, of Graceloft Ltd, had withdrawn the property from sale.
Mr Martin told the Falmouth Packet at the time: ‘All I can say is we’ve built 20 houses on that site already, we didn’t have any problem with them and there’s about eight or nine also pre-sold and we’ve got no problems with them.
‘It’s gone up in price, quite dramatically, but so have several others there, but the deals have gone through, these things happen in these times.
‘There’s over 20 houses already sold on the site that we didn’t have any difference with them, we’ve got really satisfied customers and the properties are selling well up there.
‘And yes, the property has increased in value quite considerably. Seeing as I withdrew from it, I increased the price to sell it again, but that’s only business. I don’t feel I’ve done anything wrong and that’s all I can say.’
Mr and Mrs Minshull spent thousands of pounds on solicitor fees, mortgage costs and custom wardrobes and blinds when it fell through
In a statement, Olivers Estate Agents, who were dealing with the property, said: ‘It was an unfortunate case on both sides, we can empathise on both sides of the coin.
‘We were following our instructions, as we would any of our vendors.
‘I spoke to them earlier that day to inform them that our vendor was no longer wanting to sell the property to them, for reasons between our vendor and Mr and Mrs Minshull, and that was followed up with an email confirming it.’
- For anyone who needs help, Samaritans can be contacted for free on 116 123 or visit samaritans.org to find your nearest branch.
