Joe Jonas was one of the unfortunate souls who used his “plead the fifth” option before Andy Cohen presented him with a “Marry, Shag, Kill” scenario. In his 2016 appearance on “Watch What Happens Live,” he was forced to decide among three exes. His selections were Taylor Swift, Demi Lovato, and Gigi Hadid.
Swift famously immortalized her breakup with Joe in her music, and when she appeared on “The Ellen DeGeneres Show,” she called him out for dumping her during a 25-second phone call. However, Joe reluctantly selected her as his “Shag.” He said of their relationship, “We were children.” Just like his brother Nick Jonas, Joe chose Lovato as the woman he’d put a ring on. “She’s a friend,” he explained. The exes proved this a month later when they gave a joint interview to Access Hollywood. “I have several best friends, and I definitely consider Nick and Joe as two of them, and brothers as well,” Lovato said.
Joe didn’t reveal why he wanted to give the Grim Reaper Hadid’s number, but he’d previously made his feelings known about the model rebounding with former One Direction member Zayn Malik. Three months before his “WWHL” interview, Joe told the Mirror, “I think it’s interesting that she moved on so quickly, I mean it was definitely very quick.” By the end of 2016, Joe was dating “Game of Thrones” star Sophie Turner. Unfortunately, she could now be included in his game of “Shag, Marry, Kill: Exes Edition.”
