‘You’re not my judge’: Suspect in dating-app threesome murder scene argues with investigator

Heidi Kathleen Carter (Evansville Police Department).

Heidi Kathleen Carter (Evansville Police Department).

In an emotional interrogation, a murder suspect snapped back at an investigator who confronted her with the surviving victim’s horrifying story of death and rape.

“You’re not my judge,” Heidi Kathleen Carter, 39, angrily said in footage from Oct. 20, 2021.

But jurors convicted her of charges of murder, aiding, including or causing forcible rape, and criminal confinement while armed with a deadly weapon. Cops in Evansville, Indiana, said Carter met a woman on a dating site and lured both her and the woman’s boyfriend, Tim Ivy, 50, to a home. There, Carter’s then-boyfriend, Carrey Hammond, walked in on the three having consensual sexual activity. Furious, he beat Ivy, strangled him to death, and then sexually assaulted the female victim.

You May Also Like

Woman spikes family member’s lemonade, tea with rat poison and antifreeze, then sings about Jesus on the way to jail: Cops

Barbaray Clinkenbeard (Morgan County Sheriff’s Office). A Missouri woman allegedly poisoned a…

Disturbing Photos Show Home Where Woman Allegedly Held Stepson Captive For 2 Decades

Newly released images on Monday offered a disturbing look at the Connecticut…

Man murdered parents as they slept because he thought mother stole money to rent motel room: Cops

Inset: Jason Sessoms (Van Buren County Correctional Facility). Background: Extended Stay motel…

Photos Show Home Where Emaciated Man Was Imprisoned for 20 Years

On Tuesday, officials released photos of a Connecticut home where a woman…