Biography explains that during Bushnell’s murder, Gilmore accidentally shot himself in the hand. Per Crime & Investigation UK, a mechanic working on Gilmore’s truck saw the injury, thought it was suspicious, and then called the police. Gilmore called a family member to help him with his injury but instead, they turned him in. Their efforts led to Gilmore’s swift arrest and he quickly admitted to the murders. According to A&E, Gilmore did not originally want a trial and intended to plead guilty. Nonetheless, a trial ensued and in 1976, Gilmore was convicted of murder and sentenced to death. He was given the option to die by hanging or firing squad.
Gilmore chose the latter because he believed it was a “dignified” way to go (via A&E). Forensic psychologist Joni Johnston also notes that having the opportunity to choose his means of execution provided Gilmore with a sense of “control.” ABC4 Utah reports that Gilmore was set on dying. At a pardons hearing, he stated, “I’ve simply accepted the sentence that was given to me.” Gilmore added, “I’ve accepted sentences all of my life.” Even so, his mother did not want him to die. His lawyers also attempted to appeal this decision.
Read Related Also: Nancy Grace: Roberta Laundrie’s Explanation of ‘Burn After Reading’ Letter ‘Falls Really Flat’
However, Gilmore reportedly hated prison and attempted to kill himself multiple times (via Time). He and his girlfriend, Nicole Baker Barrett, took an overdose of sleeping pills. Both survived (per UPI). Britannica states that Gilmore also attempted to starve himself, to no avail.
