Background: The office building in Carmel, Ind. where Darshan Soni worked (Google Maps). Inset: Darshan Soni (Hamilton County Jail).
An Indiana man was charged with conspiracy to commit murder after two of his co-workers told police that he allegedly tried to rope them into a plot to kill his wife.
According to court documents obtained by WXIN, a local Fox affiliate, 44-year-old Darshan Soni was accused of attempting to solicit one of his co-workers at Compass Property Group to murder his wife. An anonymous tipster, another coworker of Soni’s, reported their own interaction with the defendant during which he allegedly asked where he could purchase a silencer for a gun. The tipster reported their interactions with Soni to the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department on May 12, which kicked off the investigation into Soni.
The police said that Soni may have also allegedly attempted to kill his wife himself before turning to his co-workers.
Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.
WXIN reported that the tipster spoke with their fellow Compass employee, who reportedly said that Soni allegedly asked if he would be willing to murder his wife and what kind of price he would accept for such a task. The same employee also reportedly told Soni that he could help him create an “alibi” by holding on to his phone, making it appear that Soni was in a different location than where he intended to commit his alleged crime.
According to the court documents that were also obtained by local ABC affiliate WRTV, that employee also reportedly looked into getting cash to purchase a Ford Escape, which Soni allegedly intended to use to transport the employee who would kill Soni’s wife. Soni allegedly gave the employee $2,000 in April to put toward the car.
WRTV reported that Soni’s alleged plot was apparently in the works for months, possibly as long as a year. The employee, who cooperated with the police in exchange for immunity, told authorities that Soni had allegedly spoken with him about different kinds of poisons and criminal activities.
But before Soni allegedly turned to his co-workers for advice on how to kill his wife, he may have attempted to commit the act himself. According to the documents, Soni’s wife told police that in November 2024, she experienced “quite serious” nerve pain and sciatica, and was found to have thyroid issues earlier this year.
When police told Soni’s wife that it was possible that she had been poisoned, she revealed that a smoothie she’d had months before had an uncharacteristic “salty” taste to it. She also told them about finding a “white clumpy substance” at the bottom of one smoothie cup. When she confronted her husband about it possibly being contaminated, he reportedly disregarded her concerns and told her the substance was dishwasher detergent.
During an interview with the employee on May 14, he told police that Soni had allegedly admitted to buying “some type of poison” from India that he intended to give to his wife. The employee was also shown a photo of a wig that police believed Soni had bought. The original tipster had told police that they observed Soni retrieving the wig from the employee’s home.
According to the documents, the alleged plot to murder Soni’s wife was to unfold on May 16 at the couple’s home. Soni reportedly met with the employee he had been discussing the alleged plot with at their workplace on May 15, when they reportedly had a tense conversation about the alleged plot.
WRTV and WXIN reported that Soni apparently signaled that he wanted to back out of the alleged plot, and that he was grateful to his coworker for talking him out of it. Though WRTV reported that Soni once told the employee, “mild amounts of violence create problems, while extreme amounts solve them.”
Soni was arrested on May 16 and charged with conspiracy to commit murder. His initial court appearance was scheduled for Thursday.
