Background: The entrance to the Palm Springs, Fla., apartment complex where Michael Hall murdered his mother in 2021 (Google Maps). Inset: Michael Hall (Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office).
A Florida man who claimed he was “insane” when he bludgeoned his mother to death was sentenced to decades behind bars after entering a guilty plea.
Michael Hall, 24, was set to go on trial May 9 for murdering his mother, 53-year-old Sherri Hall, on March 16, 2021, but before jury selection began, he pleaded guilty to the crime. According to local news outlet The Palm Beach Post, Michael Hall did not go down quietly, reportedly proclaiming several times during court appearances, “I was insane!”
But rather than go to trial with an insanity defense, Michael Hall pleaded guilty to second-degree murder four years after beating his mother to death over a fight about paperwork.
Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.
According to the arrest report, police responded to reports of a deceased woman at a Palm Springs apartment on the afternoon of March 16, 2021. There they found the body of Sherri Hall with “multiple blunt injuries to her head, face, and other parts of her body” and covered in blood.
Neighbors at the apartment complex were interviewed by police and stated that they saw Michael Hall around the property that morning, “walking and pacing back and forth.” One neighbor told police that they saw Michael Hall “bleeding from his hands.” Another neighbor told police she was so alarmed by his “suspicious” behavior that she went back inside her home to wake up her husband.
The arrest report stated that Palm Springs police officers saw Michael Hall at a convenience store the morning of the murder; the officers had been called by a store clerk to conduct a welfare check on Michael Hall. While the police asked him his name, he provided a fake one — “Jake Jones” — and refused medical assistance when the officers asked him about his visible injuries.
Michael Hall was ultimately taken to a nearby hospital for an evaluation, where it was discovered he had several more injuries “consistent with a violent physical altercation.”
According to the medical examiner, Sherri Hall died of blunt trauma to the head and neck compression. At the scene, the medical examiner observed “severe” trauma to the left side of her face and that her right ear was “swollen and partially detached.” Her left arm was broken, and there were “obvious signs of great trauma” to the rest of her body.
The Palm Beach Post reported that Michael Hall’s public defenders said that their client had “freaked out” over a discussion about paperwork with his mother, who had purportedly “screamed that he needed to sign title paperwork” and ordered him to get out of the home they shared. It was then, the defense team argued, that Michael Hall “lost control and snapped.”
Michael Hall claimed that his mother physically assaulted him before he turned on her. But his defense team said “that he did not have a fully formed conscious purpose to kill” and that an “impulsive overreaction to an attack or injury is insufficient to support first- or second-degree murder.”
The public defenders also attempted to argue that Michael Hall had suffered an acute psychotic break, and doctors deemed him unfit to stand trial in 2023. That was eventually overturned.
The arrest report stated that Michael Hall gave police a “full confession” of how he murdered his mother.
Michael Hall was sentenced to 35 years in prison with credit for the four years he has been in custody since the killing.
