'Give me your Stanley': Mom jumps into daughter's argument at school, assaults girl with metal water bottle causing gash that required 17 stitches, police say

Toni Moore

Inset: Madison Evans. Background: Toni Moore at her first appearance hearing in Suffolk County, New York (WABC).

A 35-year-old mother assaulted a teen girl who was sparring with her daughter at a New York high school, authorities say.

The Suffolk County Police Department said in a press release that officers responded around 11 a.m. Tuesday to Brentwood High School on Long Island for a fight. According to cops, a 14-year-old girl was walking out of the school when she started “exchanging words” with a 15-year-old. Instead of breaking up the fight, the older girl”s mother, Toni Moore, took out a metal water bottle and walloped her daughter’s rival multiple times in the head, cops allege.

A security guard intervened and cops arrested Moore in the parking lot a short time later. She stands accused of second-degree assault and endangering the welfare of a child. The teen was taken to the hospital with non-life-threatening injuries, police said.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

The girl, Madison Evans, told New York ABC affiliate WABC she received 17 stitches on her forehead.

“Her mom just came in and started beating me with the cup,” the 10th grader told the TV station. “I touched my head because I saw blood dripping. I touched my head and I saw blood all over my hands.”

At a court hearing, Moore’s attorney reportedly said it was Evans who was the aggressor and she was at the school to meet with officials over concerns about bullying.

More from Law&Crime: ‘Oh, you’re allergic? Good’: Woman unleashed hives of bees on deputies and bystanders because she was angry about an eviction, authorities say

A video of the alleged incident reportedly shows the two girls arguing and Moore telling her daughter to “Give me your Stanley” before the alleged assault begins.

Shameakca Forney, Madison’s guardian, told WABC that Moore’s actions are unacceptable.

“She could’ve died,” she said. “Anything could’ve happened to her, more than just being hit over the head and having 17 stitches.”

At a court hearing on Wednesday, a judge released Moore on a GPS monitor.

You May Also Like

'Does not make amends for the past': Jan. 6 defendant refuses to learn from other rioters who requested restitution refunds after Trump pardon

Left inset: Donald Trump speaks at the annual Road to Majority conference…

The Search for Sustainable Aviation Fuels Is on Chopping Block

The federal spending law passed in early July 2025, often called the…

Colorado Couple Lived With Corpse of 3rd Member of Threesome for 18 Months While They Collected His Social Security Benefits

A Colorado couple has been accused of living with the corpse of…

'Going to bash her brains in': Man used hammer claw and dumbbell to slaughter 2 people with woman's help, then he began threatening her too, cops say

Inset: Johnny Morris (El Paso County Sheriff’s Office). Background: A home in…