HAILEY and Justin Bieber have been taking separate cars to events for months, according to eagle-eyed fans.
The celebrity couple has been the center of split speculation as critics pick up on various clues that their marriage is in trouble.
Hailey, 27, and Justin, 30, have been arriving and leaving star-studded events in separate cars for some time now, critics claim after examining recent photos taken of the pair.
One fan shared their concern on Reddit, asserting their opinion that the singer and model have been “living separately since last year.”
“She was forcing him on a daily paparazzi walk to convince the world that they are still together and what is said about them is not true..
“But Justin is a really bad actor because from his facial expressions and his body language you can see he is miserable as hell and he doesn’t want to be here and he is forced to do this..” the user explained alongside images of Hailey and Justin on recent outings.
“Her fans have always said that Justin hates the paparazzi and that is why he always seems unhappy, But this is not true.. Justin has been appearing with his friends or alone in front of the paparazzi recently, and he seemed normal and happier than when he was with her.. So the problem here is Hailey, not the paparazzi..” the fan continued.
“All the concerts, restaurants and places. They’ve been going too They’ve been going separately and leave separately since last year…and this doesn’t seem like a break to me because it’s been a very long time..” they closed.
TROUBLE IN PARADISE?
Justin and Hailey have been spotted separately leaving restaurants and bars in Los Angeles on multiple occasions in recent months, sparking concern among their fandom.
Cameras caught the couple walking together without touching with serious expressions or exiting venues into different vehicles and driving off by themselves.
The Rhode founder has reportedly been living apart from Justin and many of their followers believe they are using social media as a method of “damage control.”
On Sunday, Hailey shared a picture to her Instagram Stories of two Easter eggs, one with her name and one with Justin’s written in white icing.
Hailey and Justin Bieber decorate matching chocolate Easter eggs together in sweet moment as couple battles split rumors
EASTER EGG TEASE
Both of the treats were dipped in chocolate and decorated with little spring figurines in the shape of yellow ducks, orange carrots, and mini Easter bunnies.
Both were situated in small wicker baskets and were arranged on a table next to white flowers.
A third egg, dedicated to Hailey’s friend and vocalist Justin Skye, 28, was visible in the background.
The model’s decision to put her unity with her husband on display caught fan attention, with many claiming the post was forced.
Justin and Hailey’s Relationship Timeline
Photo credit: Patrick T. Fallon/AFP
Justin and Hailey go way back as she met him when she was just 12 years old during a 2009 Today show appearance.
In 2011, the two were pictured together along with Hailey’s father at Justin’s Never Say Never documentary premiere where she called him “cute.”
November 2014
- Dating rumors began after they were spotted together at a Hillsong Church service.
- During an interview with E! News, Hailey denied they were together.
- They also rung in 2015 together.
December 2015
- Dating rumors surfaced again after Hailey was spotted on vacation with Justin and his family in Tulum, Mexico.
- Later that month, they rang in the New Year again, but this time, they were spotted kissing at Leonardo DiCaprio’s New Year’s Eve party in St. Barts, according to People.
Feburary 2016
- Justin and Hailey acknowledged that they were in a relationship, but made it clear they were not exclusive.
- During another interview with E! News, Hailey said that the pair were “not an exclusive couple,” adding, “relationships at this age are already complicated, but I don’t really like to talk about it because it’s between me and him.”
- As for Justin, he spoke with GQ saying that Hailey was “someone I really love” but starting a serious relationship was not a good idea because there was already “a lot that [he had] to commit to,” including a tour.
- Later that year, the pair split in a “very dramatic excommunication,” according to People.
June 2018
- After Hailey and Justin called it quits, he got back together with Selena Gomez, but in May 2018, the pair called it quits for good.
- A few weeks later, Justin got back together with Hailey.
- “The common denominator, I promise you, is always church,” Hailey told Vogue, via People.
- “By then we were past the drama. I just gave him a hug. By the end of the conference, he was like, ‘We’re not going to be friends.’ I was like, ‘We’re not?’ “
- The pair went on to have a number of PDA-filled public appearances, confirming their relationship was back on.
July 2018
- Justin and Hailey announced their engagement.
- He popped the question during a romantic dinner in the Bahamas while they were on vacation, according to People.
- “Hailey I am soooo in love with everything about you! So committed to spending my life getting to know every single part of you loving you patiently and kindly,” Justin said in an Instagram post.
September 2018
November 2018
- Hailey changed her last name on social media from Hailey Rhode Baldwin to Hailey Rhode Baldwin Bieber.
September 2019
- Hailey and Justin had a wedding ceremony in front of their friends and family at the Montage Palmetto Bluff in Bluffton, South Carolina.
FAN THEORIES
On Reddit, one wrote, “Yet to see a photo of these two together… but she made sure to include his name on an egg.”
“If he is there, she would’ve already made sure to get a photo of them together and post it,” a second agreed.
“I feel like she is trying to do damage control as much as possible right now.”
“I absolutely agree,” a third shared, adding, “But also wonder if maybe it has a secondary purpose to make him feel guilty for not being there with her for the holiday.
“Something along the lines of, ‘I made Easter so special for us and you couldn’t even show up,’ Or not, who knows?”
“No Hailey was with the Kardashians because her egg and Justine’s egg was together with like 10+ other eggs,” a fourth asserted.
“Hailey spending holidays with Karjenners and not JB lol,” another claimed.
“Justin is nowhere near her. She’s making things worse for herself. All this faking and pretending. Then the next day she’s going to post another sad song, then make 1,000 stories about Rhode,” a final relented.
