Phyllis, who was married to Jack for a while in the middle of the 2010s, was furious when Diane came back, and the two quickly became rivals. In an effort to force Diane out of town, Phyllis teamed up with Ashley and Nikki. Phyllis and Diane’s rivalry finally came to a head when they fought, and Diane threatened to strangle Phyllis to death. 

Later, after delivering a sarcastically joyful toast to Jack and Diane following the announcement of their engagement, Phyllis fainted and was taken to the hospital. Everyone was on edge after this, yet many still had faith that Phyllis would be okay.

On Monday, April 3, however, Chance received the tragic phone call and broke the news to the group that Phyllis had been confirmed dead when her ambulance crashed and exploded.

Even though we learn of Phyllis’ death, we never see her body. And the ambulance caught fire, so even if a body is found, there is no way to positively identify it as Phyllis. In the world of soap operas, that means that it’s very unlikely that she’s really dead. After all, characters on Y&R typically don’t stay dead, especially if the death was accidental. 

As the ambulance was about to crash, Phyllis apparently came to and kept saying, “Poison, poison.” This implied that she didn’t pass out because she was sick, but because someone wanted her gone. Phyllis had been thinking of a way to get rid of Diane before she collapsed. Her own apparent death would be the perfect cover, especially since Diane had threatened to kill her. And given that Diane faked her own death back in 2011, it would make sense for Phyllis to do the same to get back at her.

So is Phyllis really dead? Absolutely not! And according to Soaps, Phyllis is alive and well, as shown in the April 5 episode.

‘Y&R’ fans react to Phyllis’ death

After Phyllis’ “death” on Y&R, viewers have four words for the show: You ain’t fooling us. No one outside the soap opera thinks for a second that she has really met her maker. Many fans have taken to social media to share their opinions on the matter.

“Obviously, Phyllis is faking her death to pin this on Diane Jenkins. She’s no better than Diane, especially when Summer and Daniel believe she is really dead. It’s wrong on so many levels. This storyline is truly whack,” commented one fan on Twitter.

Another fan added: “Of course, Phyllis isn’t dead, but not sure how any of this will bring Diane down. That fight they had wouldn’t lead to Phyllis’ collapse, so already things aren’t adding up.”

Given that there has been no mention of Michelle Stafford leaving Y&R, we can safely say there’s no way Phyllis is dead. The key mystery now is how the character being alive affects the show’s plot. Whatever the case, we are here for the drama!