Joshua Alexander Farmer (Fishers Police Dept.) and Kaylah Ann Farmer (currentobituary.com)
A 34-year-old man in Indiana will likely spend the rest of his life behind bars after admitting to stalking and killing his 33-year-old ex-wife, shooting her more than a dozen times when she stopped at a gas station.
Joshua Alexander Farmer on Thursday formally pleaded guilty to one count of murder and one count of stalking in the 2023 slaying of Kaylah Farmer, court records reviewed by Law&Crime show. In exchange for pleading guilty, prosecutors agreed to drop additional charges against Farmer, including criminal recklessness with a deadly weapon and unlawful carrying of a handgun. The plea deal also took the death penalty off the table.
The Hamilton County Prosecutor’s Office in August 2023 had filed court documents declaring its intention to seek capital punishment for Farmer, alleging he “completely emptied” the gun on his ex-wife to prevent her from testifying against him in a spate of investigations into alleged domestic violence against her and their children.
“The victim of the murder was listed by the state or known by the defendant to be a witness against the defendant and the defendant committed the murder with the intent to prevent the person from testifying,” prosecutors wrote at the time.
As Law&Crime previously reported, officers with the Fishers Police Department at about 5 p.m. on June 28, 2023, responded to a call regarding a shooting at the Speedway gas station located near 116th Street and Allisonville Road, which is about 20 miles northeast of Indianapolis.
Upon arriving at the scene, first responders said they located an adult female victim — later identified as Kaylah Ann Farmer — who appeared to have suffered multiple gunshot wounds while seated in a red Chrysler van. She was pronounced dead on the scene.
In a probable cause affidavit, police said they obtained surveillance footage from the gas station showing that Farmer pulled into the establishment shortly after his wife and “completely just unloaded [his gun] into her window,” Indianapolis NBC affiliate WTHR reported. A witness reportedly told investigators that they remembered hearing about “30 to 40 total shots” being fired during the attack.
Farmer was believed to be driving an orange or maroon-colored Kia Soul that belonged to someone else when he allegedly ambushed his ex-wife. Prior to the shooting, investigators said they believe Farmer spent the day following Kaylah Farmer before finally deciding to proceed with the alleged attack when she stopped for gas on her way home from work.
A subsequent autopsy revealed that Kaylah Farmer suffered “more than 15 gunshot wounds” throughout her body. An officer observing the procedure said that “over 25 bullet fragments were removed from Kaylah’s body,” per the affidavit.
The day after the shooting, detectives from multiple law enforcement agencies were conducting electronic surveillance in the area of the attack when one of them spotted “a pair of shoes behind a growth of shrubs and exited his vehicle,” the affidavit states. The detective said he approached the bush and “made eye contact with the subject and identified him as Joshua Farmer.” Farmer was ordered to the ground and taken into custody without incident.
Prior to his wife’s murder, Farmer was arrested on June 5 and hit with a total of 10 felonies, including confinement, strangulation, domestic battery, intimidation and pointing a firearm, records show.
In court documents filed by prosecutors in Hamilton County Superior Court, prosecutors reportedly claimed it was common knowledge that Kaylah Farmer was a victim of domestic violence at the hands of her husband and was known to wear excessive amounts of makeup to hide the bruises on her face and neck from being punched and choked.
One day after he was arrested for murder, Farmer appeared before a judge on a swath of charges from May 2023 in which he allegedly attacked Kaylah Farmer. Court documents state that Farmer’s 11-year-old son told police that he heard his father “start choking Kaylah to the point he could hear her struggling to breathe.” The child allegedly said that he “could hear the accused punching” his mother on the staircase of their home “for some time.”
The boy also told investigators about a particularly disturbing instance in which his father sat him and his mother in chairs facing each other, WTHR reported. The child reportedly said that his father then took a firearm, held it to his mother’s head, and “asked mom to choose between herself or him.”
Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.
